In-Home Medical Alert vs. Mobile GPS Medical Alert Solutions

AllsWell Team

Table of contents:


In the US, emergency department visits reach 40.4 per 100 persons. These are 130 million visits in total. It shows how often people need medical help and how vulnerable specific groups are. Adults living alone and seniors are at an exceptionally high risk since they spend the most time on their own. Even when something minor happens, nobody is there to help.

In-home medical alert systems and mobile GPS medical alert devices may be a solution. They support the panic button that allows users to ask for help in emergencies. Some of the best in-home medical alert systems and GPS alerts also have inactivity monitoring.

So what kind of services do you need? When are in-home medical alert devices better than mobile solutions and vice versa? Keep reading to find out.

What is an In-Home Medical Alert System? How Does it Work?

In-home medical alert systems are devices with a panic button connected to an emergency dispatcher. When the user clicks the panic button, they can communicate with emergency services to ask for help. If necessary, the dispatcher will send an ambulance to the location where the in-home medical alert solution is installed.

In-home medical alert devices consist of several components. They have a base unit users place in their houses and pendants they keep at hand. You can have several pendants connected to the same system if you live with a spouse, for example.

Even though many modern in-house systems support wearables, they still require in-house installation. A specific location is the main characteristic that differentiates them from mobile systems. Besides, they often have a fall detection feature that mobile alerts don't usually support.

What Is a Mobile GPS Medical Alert System? How Does it Work?

Mobile medical alert systems with GPS tracking are wearable devices and apps that send emergency alerts with the user's location. Unlike in-house solutions, they are designed for not homebound and independent people. These may be users who commute to work, travel, go jogging, or do any other outside activity alone.

Mobile GPS medical alerts are offered as separate devices or mobile apps. Devices are watches, lockets, pendants, and other wearables with a panic button and a GPS tracker. Apps are Android or iOS applications you can download to any modern smartphone to power it with a panic button and other features. They will request geolocation permission to use GPS tracking on the connected phone.

Since these medical devices are wearable, location detection is a critical feature along with the panic button. When the user activates emergency alerts, they must include GPS coordinates to allow emergency contacts to find the person. Mobile GPS medical alert systems send notifications to selected contacts and usually don't support emergency response center monitoring.

Pros & Cons: In-Home vs. Mobile Medical Alert Systems With GPS

It's challenging to find a universal solution for all kinds of emergencies. The best in-home medical alert systems and devices have different pros and cons. Whereas in-house solutions protect you at home, wearables ensure mobility outdoors.

In-Home Medical Alert Systems


  • Classic and reliable

  • Connect users to emergency response dispatchers

  • Users always know where the panic button is

  • Eliminate the need always to keep the device at hand

  • Support fall detection apart from the panic button


  • They won’t protect you outside

  • Not suitable for adults who work or travel alone

  • Usually more expensive than mobile solutions and apps

Mobile Medical Alert Systems With GPS


  • Users can carry them anywhere

  • More affordable than in-house systems with emergency response center monitoring

  • Support inactivity monitoring apart from the panic button

  • Allow sending alerts to selected contacts instead of calling emergency for less critical situations

  • Convenient and lightweight

  • May not require an additional device (if you choose a mobile safety app with GPS tracking)


  • Users are more likely to lose a mobile device 

  • Don’t call an emergency response dispatcher

Based on the listed advantages and disadvantages, it should be easier to understand what solution you need. It all depends on who the end-user is and what lifestyle they have. You can get a medical alert system for personal use or buy it for your loved ones.

When Use In-Home vs. Mobile GPS Medical Alert Systems

Note that neither in-home medical alerts systems nor mobile GSP notifications are suitable for medical monitoring. Both solutions protect people who live or spend a lot of time alone and want a reliable way to ask for help if something happens. Patients with severe health issues or those who may need immediate medical help should use specialized equipment.

In-Home Medical Alert Systems

In-house solutions are best for seniors and people with limited mobility who rarely leave their homes. These user categories can benefit from a system with fall detection and emergency response center support. Caregivers buy such solutions to ensure their dear ones can ask for help whenever they need it. It brings them peace of mind and simplifies carings for seniors.

In-home medical alert devices are also preferable for people who love classic solutions regardless of their age. In-home systems may be simpler to use than mobile apps and look more familiar. Users always know where the base unit with the panic button is.

Mobile Medical Alert Systems With GPS

Mobile solutions with GPS are suitable for users who move a lot. These may be active seniors with mild health issues or adults who live, travel, commute, or work alone. When a person has a device or mobile app with the panic button at hand, they can always ask for help.

Mobile GPS medical alert systems are also more multifunctional than in-home solutions. Apart from reporting health issues, you can use them for personal security. Since mobile solutions send alerts to selected contacts (e.g., friends or family), they are applicable in a broader range of situations. For example, you can activate alerts if you get lost during a trip, or something threatens your safety.

AllsWell for Instant Alerts and Inactivity Monitoring

AllsWell Alert is a personal safety & emergency alert app for people living, commuting, or traveling alone. It combines the panic button functionality with inactivity monitoring, enabling the app to send your emergency contact an alert with your location even when you cannot press a button. It’s an easy way to stay safe and mobile.

Join AllsWell free for a month to test how mobile GPS alerts work and enhance personal safety.

Start your free 30 day trial in 3 easy steps

Start your free trial

33ยข/day or less after that

Try for free